Interesting. I just discovered there is no "Start a Conversation" button for a user I'm trying to PM. That user is a Gold Member. At first I thought it was just me but then I had a friend (also a GC member) try and he doesn't have that option either. I can click on almost anyone else's name and there it is: Start a Conversation, but not this one. Anyway, I don't know why I'm posting this here other than to say, if you're not receiving any PM offers or messages on your For Sale ads here, maybe you have that function turned off? Or maybe it's voodoo witchcraft, I dunno.